The Smiley Favorite 2's and 3's are very similar from what I recall. Will check mine...
Hello Jeff, I am currently putting a set of them Smileys together. Have you got a picture of a 2? I don't recall seeing a 2. And have you got any extras laying around in your way? If so I'll let you know what I need. I got a 3 and a 1 at an auction on Tuesday.
I think Favorite was all over the place on them Smileys. By that, I mean wherever they could get a pattern, because they did use patterns from Wagner and Griswold. For instance, I got a 12 Smiley, its got an outside heat ring, and that is an old pattern, its got a Wagner Ghost on it and I believe "ERIE" also. And then I have a 13 Smiley and its got an inside heat ring and an all together different pattern, later, much refined, with an assist handle one piece and not open like Wagner.