Who Made the Best Skillet?

[Cheryl Watson]

Shane asked for it (and Albert suggested it)... here it is! ;D

[Albert Hutchison]

Thanks Cheryl it will be very interesting to see how it comes out. :) GO GRISWOLD almost as fun as watch football !!!!!!!

[Cheryl Watson]

Yep! And the Poll author took the liberty of adding pre-Griswold ERIE's.... guess you can figure where the author stands...... ;) ;) ;) ;)

[Albert Hutchison]

LOL

[Roger Barfield]

SS would point out that it really isn't pre-Griswold as it is Griswold.  It's just the logo they used at the time.   ;) ;D ::)

[Cheryl Watson]

SS would point out that it really isn't pre-Griswold as it is Griswold.  It's just the logo they used at the time.   ;) ;D ::)

I know... I know... ::) ::)
But poll author decided they deserved a class category, all their own! ::) ::)

So in an effort to clarify and please all, poll author has now slightly adjusted the category descriptions.... :D

Go ERIE's ! :) 8-)

PS.....But Roger, that's what they call them on Ebay! ::) ::)

[Frank Burkhead]

Ahh, but best for what? I love cooking on my Wapak and Erie skillets, but love the look of gate marked pans and Indian heads hanging on my wall most of all. Since Wapak made the Indian heads, my vote goes to....  ;D

[Stuart Lowery]

My cooking experience is limited to Wagner and Lodge (I've "collected" a few others, but no cooking) so I don't feel qualified to vote.

But, I thought that if it was flat, smooth, and well-seasoned, then they were all the "best" ;)

[Cheryl Watson]

Hey, ask Shane what he meant...
http://www.griswoldandwagner.com/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.pl?num=1384873289

He started it.... ;D

Best Collectible???

[Karen Kale]

Like Stuart, I don't feel I've cooked in enough different varieties to qualify for an official vote, so I'll have to abstain.

But unofficially, I'm with the poll author. Those skillets are amazing!

[Cheryl Watson]

I collect more than I cook with!!!

So vote..vote... vote...!! :) :)

[Nick Niacaris]

I cook with everything I've collected so far.  ;D

[Claudia Killebrew]

I really don't have enough of a variety to give a well versed opinion. However, of the ones I do have, I love my Favorite Piqua and Wapak.

[C. B. Williams]

I will cook with anything except pieces that still have their label and the famous "last piece" griddle with the initials cast on the bottom. My favorite skillet to cook with is the large block smooth bottoms. I only collect Griswold so I don't know about the other brands.

[Albert Hutchison]

I will cook with anything except pieces that still have their label and the famous "last piece" griddle with the initials cast on the bottom. My favorite skillet to cook with is the large block smooth bottoms. I only collect Griswold so I don't know about the other brands.

C.B. YOU ARE THE 1 THAT OWNS THAT GRIDDLE???? YOU ARE A GOD OF COLLECTING AND NOT TO BAD OF A COOK.....

[Cheryl Watson]

Giving a little ... BuMp....
Where have all the CHF fans gone??

Us ERIE fans are ahead by a nose...... :P

[C. B. Williams]

Albert: That would be me. You can see it in the section labeled "previous eye candy". C B

[Cheryl Watson]

Thought I would bump this back up so our Newer Folks can Vote too!

[Albert Hutchison]

Thanks because us  Griswold fans needs more votes over your should I say it eire fans ( same as griswold but just older lol ) :D

[Dwayne Henson]

I like those old gate marked skillets! Nice light weight, and being like Will, usually pretty cheap!